Are PEOs Taking Your Tax Credits?

June 22, 2025 | Denise Gelfand

What Business Owners Should Know About WOTC, R&D, and Other Incentives

If your business uses a PEO (Professional Employer Organization) for payroll, HR, and compliance, you might be losing out on valuable federal and state tax credits without even knowing it.  

Why?

Because PEOs often file taxes under their own EIN as the employer of record, which means they may be claiming credits your business earned for themselves.

In this article, you’ll learn:

  • Which federal and state tax credits are at risk using a PEO
  • Why your PEO may be the one benefiting
  • How employer status affects your eligibility
  • What you can do to protect or reclaim your incentives

Tax Credits at Risk When Using a PEO

Businesses working with a PEO may unknowingly lose access to the following high-value tax credits:

✅ Federal Tax Credits

    • Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC)
      • Worth between $2,400 to $9,600 per eligible hire. 
      • Applies to hiring target groups such as veterans, long-term unemployed, and SNAP recipients.
      • Requires pre-screening and certification within 28 days of the employee’s start date.  

⚠️ Since the PEO is typically the employer of record, they file the paperwork under their EIN, making them the credit recipient, not you. 

Many businesses lose out because the PEO doesn’t flag eligible hires.

  • FICA Tip Credit 
    • Available to restaurants, bars, hospitality, and service businesses with tipped employees.
    • Offsets the employer share of FICA taxes on tips above the federal minimum wage, currently $7.25/hour.

⚠️ PEOs may retain this credit or fail to assign it to your tax account.

  • Research & Development Credit
    • Offsets up to 6-8% of qualified research expenses against federal income tax liability.  
    • Eligible businesses can also apply up to $500,000 annually to offset payroll taxes.  

⚠️These credits often get absorbed or misallocated unless the PEO properly assigns them back to your EIN.

✅ State and Local Tax Credits 

States also offer rich credits and incentives for:

  • Hiring and workforce training
  • R&D and innovation
  • Expanding operations in target regions

Examples include:

State

Credit/Incentive

California

New Employment Credit, ETTP Training Grants

Texas

Skills Development Fund

Georgia

Job Tax Credit, Retraining Credit

New York

Youth Jobs Program

Florida

Quick Response Training 

Louisiana

Quality Jobs Program

Arizona

R&D and Job Training Credits

⚠️ These credits are designed to support you, the hiring business, but they often require employers to file directly under their own state ID.  If your PEO is filing taxes and incentives under their name, the credits may not be coming your way. 

🧾 The Core Issue: Employer of Record vs. Common Law Employer

The IRS and states differentiate between two types of employers:

👥 Common Law Employer (That’s You)

You’re the one who:

  • Determines compensation
  • Hires and fires
  • Directs day-to-day work
  • Controls business operations

🏛️ Employer of Record (Usually the PEO)

They:

  • File payroll taxes under their EIN
  • Manage tax reporting and W-2s
  • Handle unemployment insurance accounts
  • Often submits forms for tax credits under their name

! When your PEO is the employer of record, they often end up in the legal position to claim tax credits, unless your agreement specifically assigns those credits to you.  Most business owners never know to ask.

🛡️ How to Protect Your Tax Credit Eligibility

Here’s how you can safeguard your access to tax credits, whether you stay with a PEO or plan to exit one:

1. Review Your Contract

Look for clauses related to:

  • “Tax incentives”
  • “WOTC” or “hiring incentives”
  • “Assignment of benefits”
  • “Employer of record” responsibilities

If these are vague or missing, assume the PEO keeps the credits.

2. Ask Your PEO These Questions

  • Who applies for state and federal tax credits—us or you?
  • Are credits tracked under our EIN or yours?
  • If you file for them, do we receive the full value or do you take a percentage?
  • Is this detailed in our contract?

3. Negotiate or Exit

  • Request credit-sharing clauses be added to your agreement
  • Move to a CPEO (Certified PEO) which may allow client retention of credits
  • Transition away from a PEO model entirely

📉 How Much Could You Be Losing?

Even a modest-sized company can leave tens of thousands per year on the table:

Credit Type

Example Annual Loss (Est.)

WOTC (5 qualified hires)

$20,000–$40,000

FICA Tip Credit

$5,000–$30,000

Federal R&D Credit

$25,000–$100,000+

State Hiring Credits

Varies widely

📌 Final Thoughts

While PEOs can offer some convenience, it shouldn’t come at the cost of your business’s incentives. Whether you’re growing, hiring, training, or innovating, those tax credits were designed to support you, the business owner, not the PEO. 

PEO arrangements can make it difficult to navigate varying requirements and claim these credits effectively.

PostPEO helps businesses evaluate their PEO arrangements, uncover hidden costs, and find cost-effective alternative solutions.